Facts verified July 2026 · sources named on every quote
PlotToTable vs Seedtime.
An honest comparison, including the rows they win. Seedtime: Free tier (1 calendar, built-in crops). Basic $84/yr; Unlimited $168/yr (or $20 monthly). PlotToTable: free plan forever, Premium $7.99/mo, $59/yr, or $129 once for life.
Feature by feature
The table. We win 8, they win 1.
| Feature | PlotToTable | Seedtime |
|---|---|---|
| Starting point | What your family eats; we compute the garden backward | A calendar you populate crop by crop |
| Price for everything | $59/yr or $129 once for life | $168/yr for Unlimited |
| Plant counts for your household | Computed from servings per week | You decide quantities |
| Planting dates | Your ZIP code's frost dates | Frost-date based calendar (US-centric) |
| Adapts when you fall behind | One-click replan from today | Auto-rescheduling task list (their best feature) |
| Succession planting | Re-sow cadence built into every plan row | Automated on paid tiers |
| Keep your data if you stop paying | Yes, forever | Free tier remains, paid features lock |
| Live neighborhood pest alerts | Yes, free (community Pest Radar) | No |
| AI plant doctor with your garden's context | Yes, free 3/day | Sprout chat answers general questions only |
| Grocery-savings math | $-value per crop, tracked against real harvests | No |
| Education library & community | Guides and recipes, no video course library | Large lesson library + active community |
| Add custom varieties | Yes, free accounts get 5, Premium unlimited | Paid tiers only |
Credit where due
What Seedtime does well.
- A genuinely permanent free tier, rare in this category.
- The calendar auto-reschedules missed tasks, the only incumbent that adapts mid-season.
- Succession-planting automation on paid tiers.
- A loyal community, founder-led support, and a large lesson library.
What their users say
The complaints, sourced.
“Their emails are predatory to get more money out of you for constant classes and they're blatantly written with AI.”
Trustpilot, 1-star review
“I found this cumbersome to use and an overload of detailed info that did not apply to me.”
Trustpilot, community-garden user
“The guy who made the program goes through everything so fast that I can't keep up.”
realreviews.io, onboarding videos
“Screens still seem a bit sluggish, I find myself having to exit them and come back.”
realreviews.io
The honest verdict
Seedtime earned its following: the auto-rescheduling calendar is genuinely good and the community is real. But you pay $168 a year for the full product, quantities are still on you to figure out, and the savings math does not exist. PlotToTable starts from your plate, computes the counts, costs a third as much for everything, and the whole starter plan is free.
Common questions
Isn't Seedtime also free?
Seedtime's free tier is a single calendar with built-in crops only. PlotToTable's free tier is a complete computed plan: plant counts for your household, ZIP-code sow dates, a bed map, and a season calendar, with the first 3 crops in full detail.
Seedtime auto-reschedules tasks. Does PlotToTable?
PlotToTable's answer is one-click 'Replan from today': the engine recomputes every date from the current day, including skipped windows and next succession rounds. Same outcome, one button, no task-list grooming.
Which is cheaper?
For the full product: PlotToTable Premium is $59/yr or $129 once for life. Seedtime Unlimited is $168/yr with no lifetime option. Over three seasons that's $129 once versus about $504.
Competitor pricing and features verified July 2026 from their public pages and user reviews; they change things, so check their site for current terms. Other comparisons: vs GrowVeg Garden Planner
Try the difference in 60 seconds.
Six questions, no email, no card. If it's not for you, you lost a minute.